Weekly Update

Christian Nationalism isn’t dead yet.

The midterms didn’t kill the White Christian Nationalist movement. They may have just made it more desperate.

After the midterms, headlines abounded with promises that Christian Nationalism was dead and the culture-war was over. Wouldn’t that be nice?

But when has being unpopular ever stopped religious extremists? Fascistic movements don’t need majority support. And vampires aren’t keen to pack up once you’ve invited them in. Likewise, the far-right fanatics who made it through the Overton window have no intention of crawling back from whence they came, which would mean abdicating all the power they’ve gained in the past decade.

“White people are not going to go quietly,” said Joel Webbon to attendees at his recent Christ Is King: America After Trump conference. “We’re done with equality… Christianity is American. Islam is not. Hinduism is not. Judaism is not.”

Webbon, who believes in repealing women’s right to vote, criminalizing abortion and homosexuality, and barring non-Christians from public office, used his opening remarks to demand a purely Christian nation, mass deportations for anyone who isn’t a “heritage American,” a ban of interracial marriage, “ending the hatred of men,” an acknowledgment that Jews are the most wicked people in history, and recognition that “Christ is King” — a phrase American Atheists’ policy team has been monitoring in state legislatures since its co-option by religopolitical extremists. 

It was a sentiment echoed by many speakers at the conference — including conspiracy theorist and conman Alex Jones, neo-Nazi Nick Fuentes, and British cleric Calvin Robinson, who this week said, “[The United States] is an explicitly Christian land for an explicitly Christian people,” and, “I think driving out the Jews is the answer.” 

Theo-bro Dale Partridge gave a speech titled “Love Your Neighbor By Deporting Him,” and said, “The Hindu on our welfare system who is defrauding our country through hospice scams is not my neighbor in the same way that the heritage American is.”

During one panel, failed Florida gubernatorial candidate James Fishback said, “[The] demographic replacement of our country must come to an end, and we must remigrate every last one of them.” 

This was a not-at-all-veiled reference to the “Great Replacement” conspiracy theory, which claims that elites are plotting to replace white people with non-white immigrants. According to the Global Project Against Hate And Extremism, believers in this theory have been behind “an astounding number of mass casualty terrorist attacks across the globe in recent years.”

“Remigration” is the forced deportation of migrants to create a homogenous society. In fewer words: ethnic cleansing. Once relegated to the Naziest of fringes, the idea has made its way into the halls of power. The Trump Administration opened an “Office of Remigration” within the U.S. Department of State. 

That cleric who called for “driving out the Jews”? He was invited to speak by White House Faith director Paula White through her National Faith Advisory Board at an event where she also promoted Rededicate 250 — the Christian worship event on the National Mall American Atheists is suing over. 

And Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, who recently survived a failed impeachment attempt, invited Christian Nationalist Doug Wilson back to the Pentagon this week, where he sermonized in favor of a Christian theocracy, arguing that all systems of government are already theocratic: “It is not whether we impose morality, but rather which morality we impose… We are Christians, so we do not want a demented morality.” 

So, if you’re tempted, like some commentators were, to look at the midterms and conclude these guys are finished, allow me to borrow from Monty Python: They’re not quite dead yet. And a desperate movement is a dangerous one. 

According to Webbon, losing the midterms was the convenient first step in his six-year plan to put a real White Christian Nationalist in the White House. Fishback already announced plans to run for president in 2028. 

Just this week, Pew Research Center projected that Muslims will outnumber Christians globally in less than a decade. For a movement obsessed with being replaced, terrified of losing relevance, and unburdened by any comprehension of statistics, it isn’t difficult to imagine where this could lead.

Meanwhile, their leaders will keep egging them on, telling them that equality is oppression and pluralism is persecution. Stephen Miller — a bombastic believer in the Great Replacement, a supporter of remigration, and recently promoted to Chief of Staff — has vowed to expand mass deportations in the next year.

So, no, I’m sorry to tell you the midterms didn’t kill the White Christian Nationalist movement. They may have just made it more desperate. And, as Webbon warned, desperate movements don’t tend to go quietly — especially when their hateful views have been normalized and their leaders empowered. 

American Atheists isn’t going away either. With your continued support, we’ll keep exposing this movement, challenging its influence, and opposing its efforts to turn our democracy into a theocracy.

About the Author

More Recent Updates