A federal appeals court on Monday upheld a Texas law that requires public school students to observe a daily minute of silence in order to pray, reflect or otherwise remain quiet.
A three-judge panel from the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans affirmed a district court ruling, saying the law is constitutional because it expressly allows any silent use of that minute, whether religious or not. Read More
Can we please stop playing around with “moments of silence” and pretending they are secular? All moments of silence are inherently religious and therefore have no place in the classroom. They are tools to remind non-religious kids that they are in a minority. They are there to exert peer pressure, and nothing else.
Consider:
1) In every public school in the country, every kid can pray whenever s/he wants to. They can bring a bible/koran/whatever to class, read it during recess, pray before meals, etc. The only thing they can’t do is disrupt class or other people when they do it (Hint: those who don’t pray in school today, don’t WANT to pray).
2) Every public school in the country has the right to allow prayer groups on their property, before or after class, for sectarian prayer. The only thing they can’t do is require attendance and officially sponsor it. Most schools allow them, and the only ones who don’t attend are the ones who don’t want to attend. See where I’m going?
3) In church, prayer is not required, and neither is attendance. You can go when you want, and pray if you want. If you go to a church you will be required to stay silent while other people pray around you, but you will never be forced to pray. Sound familiar?
Now we have a law in Texas that says this is not enough. Now, EVERY kid MUST attend. They don’t need to pray (like a church), but unlike church, and religious clubs in schools, attendance is MANDATORY. Every kid MUST go and behave like they would in church, every day. Parents may not opt out. Kids may not opt out. Stand there and keep quiet while we (the school) apply peer pressure on you to pray. We can’t TELL you to pray, but we can make you feel really uncomfortable if you don’t. And we can also make sure those kids who DO pray see that you don’t, so you may be further ostracized.
To say moments of silence is not forced attendance of a religious event is analogous to Utah saying the cross is not a religious symbol. It’s a lie, used to circumvent the law.







