You know how those in the Religious Right are constantly directing God to strike down those they don’t like? Isn’t what’s good for one, also good for the other then? Actually, God didn’t strike down the Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez or the pro-Roe v Wade Justices. But a couple of years ago he did strike down all the Republican districts in Florida with several hurricanes and then came yesterday.The Washington Post reports that 44 persons died yesterday in storms that swept throughout the South, mostly in the states of Tennessee and Arkansas just hours after those states finished voting for Mike Huckabee to be the Republican candidate for President.I would quit invoking the name of God like the Religious Right keeps doing if I was them. God did say, don’t use his name in vain. Good for us, bad for them if they keep refusing to learn their own lessons. I’ll be okay since I was never going to vote for Huckabee anyways. But if I was a Christian, I’d think twice before pressing that little button for Mike in the future primaries.Peter Nuhn
I really don’t think using the deaths of 44 (now 47) people to make a pro-atheist point is in good taste, Peter. We atheists have enough of a public perception problem as it is. That was a stupid and crass thing to say.
yeah, a little crass.
Dude – uncool.
I live in Indiana, directly across the river from Kentucky and I spent last night huddled with my nine month old daughter in our basement while storms tore up our neighborhood.
I don’t really find the humor or relevance in this post. As an atheist, I know that death is final…these people are not going to some magic place in the sky. Let’s have some sympathy. Not all of them voted or were involved.
Not a good post.
Let’s not stoop to the level of the irrationals, please.
I don’t think Peter meant it as offensive, but yeah, I agree with those above, we should be a bit more cautious in what we say, especially when it is in others pain and loss.
I don’t think Peter meant it as offensive, but yeah, I agree with those above, we should be a bit more cautious in what we say, especially when it involves others pain and loss.
But Peter still has a point: it’s always sauce for the goose but never for the gander when it comes to the hypocrisy of the bible-thumpers.
When have you ever heard one of them blame their “omnibenevolent” Jeebuz (i.e. giving credit where credit is due) when just the opposite happens of what they’ve been praying for? Yet they’re all too ready to point out how it’s the Lawd’s divine retribution when bad stuff happens to their enemies. Nothing but silence when bad stuff happens to them themselves; where is their recognition that perhaps divine retribution has now been divinely distributed? Oh, no, not them — they’re the “anointed” ones, the righteous, a sweet smell in the Lawd’s nostrils.
I feel inclined to cut Peter a little slack on this one, for making a point, regardless of the fact he could have addressed it from a better frame. We’re none of us perfect.
I understand Peter’s point, but I hope that if I had died last night in the storm that you would not use me as some worthless analogy to prove a point.
Also, don’t tell me I am irrational when I was going through the fear of losing my family, home, car, mother, father, friends, etc…
I was dealing with it and I gave an honest response. To me, my view is rational.
@ Celebrant Prince
I’m sorry, but there can be no justification for using the deaths of people as a means to make a ideological point. There is no question that the deluded religious wack-jobs use this sort of tactic (like blaming Ellen DeGeneres for Hurricane Katrina), but that is no excuse for this kind of disrespectful comment.
In fairness, this does seem out of character for Peter. Perhaps he should consider updating the post with an apology of some sort.
Podry,
I don’t think you were being irrational by any stretch. Many a night my wife and I had to take cover in the basement of the school house in which we lived ? in rural Nebraska ? from the threat of tornados.
We even once (about three years ago) had a car completely totaled by hail. I mean totaled.
Storms of that nature are a terrifying thing.
Podry,
By the way, I lived 10 minutes from the spot where the largest discovered hail stone in the U.S. was documented (Aurora, NE). It was nearly the size of a soccer ball.
It was that storm that destroyed our car.
It wasn’t fun to watch.
Sheesh! That was actually five years ago! Man, time flies!
Found this from December 13, 2006:
i dont think anyone is saying it’s justice that this happened to these people, simply pointing out an irony.
it’s a sad thing that they weren’t able to get to shelter.
what would be just is if the tornado had come down on huckabees hotel room and sunk a bible into his bloated stomach.
“Tragedy is when I cut my finger. Comedy is when you walk into an open sewer and die.”
- Mel Brooks
Peter,
I have to agree with some others here that your original post does come across as a bit insensitive. Had you posted Robertson’s blurb in your original post, your point would have come across a lot better by comparison.
But indeed, your point is made, as the current main headline on cnn.com is:
Tornado survivor: ‘I was calling on Jesus’
@ Peter quoting me from http://www.atheists.org/nogodblog/index.php/2006/12/13/seasonal_feel_good_stories#c55789:
I’m not sure what your point is for quoting the comment I made in that earlier post. Everyone knows that Pat Robertson is a lunatic. That isn’t justification for using horrible deaths to make a point. “Rise above them!” I say, if you’ll excuse the weak resurrection reference.
The PC bandwagon rolls on, against Peter this day.
Of course, all of you are ignoring the fact that religious retards frequently make these kinds of claims and enjoy a place in the national spotlight for it.
Peter isn’t out to injure the memory of those that died in these storms. He’s being satirical. If some of you can stop your hearts from bleeding for just a minute, you might recognize that no offense was intended.
I can’t often side with Peter for political reasons. I simply can’t find reasons to admire the tow-the-line variety (on any subject, politics included) – it’s as bad as the faithers.
Still, I’ve even agreed with Phreedm on points in the past;clearly, stranger things have happened.
Recognize the satire for what it is and apologize to Peter for your accusations that he was being callous. Dead people don’t need you to stick up for them and they clearly have no capacity to care if you do or don’t. Peter is alive and has the capacity to care about how you treat him. Remember that.
Yeah, and we all give them shit for it.
So is he. Read it again, then read his followup post if you still don’t get it.
i think any xians that read this will have to take it as “an eye for an eye” and grow a thicker skin. death is part of life, peter was clearly joking, and i forgot my final point, but it was a doosey!
WTF. I can’t believe all of these responses to the post. Yes, in a way it was crass because people died. On the other hand, what are you folks trying to do, make the Xians LOVE YOU??!!! I come from a long line of idiot xians, and in my opinion you really should give up the idea that they will ever ever love you or respect you. They want you dead and burning in hell to the glory of god. I love this kind of crass humor, can’t get enough of it. Give us more, lordy, lordy! And yes, I agree with the poster above who points out that this is PRECISELY what the idiot xians do ALL THE TIME. God is constantly “punishing” the sinful–New Orleans, The World Trade Towers, Etc. Get a grip, folks, you will always be a minority–get used to it and enjoy it. It will be several million years before the religious “gene” gets “squeezed out” of the gene pool, if then.
I get it, AT. What’s sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander. But the satire doesn’t even work on its own terms. The headline says “God Strikes Down Huckabee Voters.” To be satirizing what Peter claims to be satirizing, it should say something like “God Punishes States of Tennessee, Arkansas for Voting Huckabee.”
You know the old saying “comedy = tragedy + time”? You can’t leave “time” out of the equation.
The Celebrant Prince smugly observes that “it’s always sauce for the goose but never for the gander when it comes to the hypocrisy of the bible-thumpers.”
Who hungers for this foul sauce?
In an epoch when feminists and Negroes salivate over the chance to behave as badly as their erstwhile oppressors, it is sad to see a more rational demographic stoop to such crass opportunism. It’s neither nice nor funny to make light of tragedy.
It’s pointless and counter-productive–jackass…
Just because it has been done before doesn’t mean it’s OK…
off-topic
the building codes in these states have they been updated in recent yrs.i know i sound screwball but we should have some data that can be useful in preventing lose of life.at the very least every building should be required to have a fallout shelter.
I seem quite outvoted by the other commenters in my qualified support for Peter’s satire; I appreciate and understand the opposing points of view. I might point out though, that in no way can I sense Peter Nunh glorying in the tragic deaths of others, as has all too often been the case when the fundies get up on their soapboxes.
I’ll let it rest at that. See you all in the next thread. Goodnight.
Peter
Joking about the deaths of fellow human beings the DAY AFTER is just not cool. Whats more you made the huge assumption that the deceased were Huckabee supporters just to make this strained “joke”. Not cool.
It is a mistake in judgment that we can all learn from. I am sure Peter did not mean ill, it just came across that way.
O?Hair was insensitive, crass and immoral. She was an embarrassment, even with her accomplishments. We have to be better than her and set a higher standard.
AT,
last I heard 47 people died, I would have accepted a discussion of how the ideologues decide when to say god did it and when to say god saved me, but SATIRE IS callous in this case. we’re not trying to be PC, we’re trying to be compassionate.
I just had to register to respond to this. If I ever die in an accident or unfortunate event, feel free to use my death as a source of material to attack any irrational fundy you want.